Grammatical
Summary
Confusion
with Other Sentence Structures
Other Function of that
A problem with identifying English relative
clauses is that the same words that serve as relative clause
introducers have other functions. The word that
is used as a demonstrative pronoun as in that
book or I
find that interesting. The word that
is also used to introduce that-clauses
(sometimes called noun clauses) as in the sentence
below.
The photographer said that
the image should be
enlarged.
Wh-Words/Phrases in Other Embedded Structures
In addition to introducing relative clauses,
wh-words
and phrases are used to introduce various kinds of embedded
sentence structures as in the following sentences:
The professor asked who
was interested in digital photography.
The students were arguing about whose
camera should be used for the project.
Unlike relative clauses, that-clauses
and these embedded wh-clauses
occur in positions that regular noun phrase objects can occur
in. Compare the above three sentences with the following three
sentences:
The photographer said something.
The professor asked a
question.
The students were arguing about a
decision.
A relative clause, on the other hand, occurs
inside a noun phrase and modifies the noun that it immediately
follows.
Of course, another function of wh-words
and phrases is that they are used in wh-questions
as in the following examples:
Who
did you buy that scanner from?
From whom
did you buy a scanner?
Which scanner did you buy?
Whose scanner did you buy?
|