Fram Chair Award for Excellence in Applied Critical Thinking at Imagine
The Fram Chair seeks to recognize excellence in the application of critical thinking that was used in the preparation and creation of an exhibit at Imagine RIT. This recognition is not for the exhibit itself, but the thought processes used to arrive at or create the exhibit.
Application of critical thinking connects the performance chain of knowing-doing-creating. At RIT, applied critical thinking is engaged thinking used to effectively comprehend and analyze a context, develop a point of view, and implement a strategy to solve a complex problem or creatively manifest new ideas, both individually and collectively.
Any team presenting or exhibiting at Imagine RIT
At least one of the team members must be an actively enrolled RIT student
Note: The names of all RIT contributors (RIT students, faculty, staff) must be listed on the application, and the group type (small group, large group) must be specified.
If you would like to apply for the RIT Fram Chair Award for Excellence in Applied Critical Thinking at Imagine, please complete a nomination form when the application process opens.
All deadlines must be met in order for the application to be considered, and the final exhibit must be presented at Imagine RIT. Applications are closed for 2022.
Winners will be announced prior to Imagine RIT and award certificates will be presented at Imagine RIT in the spring.
Awarded groups will share $250 Tiger Bucks.
This year the committee seeks to recognize excellence in the following categories:
Abstract: This project explores the combination of traditional art with modern technology. By overlaying augmented reality on woodblock prints, Marie is discussing the complex nature of mental illness. Each AR experience is based around a particular mental illness. The goal is to evoke a sense of empathy in the viewer by discussing mental illness in a visual way, beyond a diagnosis or definition, since mental health is more of an experience than something concrete.
2022 Large Group Award: GET HEALTHY GET RITch®: Interactive Platform, Simulation and Digital Tools
Team: Caleb Vaccaro, Marc Molnar, Kevan Beemsteboer, Tirzah Pilet, Deon Allen, Kristy Kelley, Qian Li, Mini Mathai, Marielsy Pimentel, Kalpana Sundaram, Noora Abdulkerim, Tim Baer, Jaime Elizabeth Blackmon, Thomas Chacko, Eljada Gjoka, Dustin Haraden, Kayci Hauser, Joanne Raptis, Constance Rose, Siena Tugendrajch, Leah Ward, Johnathan Wright, Dr. Cassandra Berbary, Dr. Caroline Easton, Dr. Cory Crane, Dr. Richard Doolittle, Dr. Tory Toole, Dr. Rupa Kalahasthi and Dr. Celeste Sangiorgio
Abstract: Research indicates that approximately 50% of individuals who experience a substance use disorder also experience a co-occurring mental health condition; however, more than half of these individuals do not receive treatment. The introduction of technology into the mental health field promises to combat many of the barriers to receiving treatment. Technology based treatment tools allow for a low cost, efficient, comprehensive, and sustainable platform that can be widely distributed. This interactive exhibit highlights the use of technology-based behavioral health tools including a behavioral health avatar coach, a 3D substance use prevention tool, and a digital emotion measurement tool.
The Fram Advisory Board also recognizes these teams as Honorable Mentions:
Team: Anna Leung, Will Salerno, Devin Kirkwood, Simon Morrier, Dylan Gomer, Hun Choi, Andy Huang and Andrew Beach
Abstract: Jungle Jam is the bridge between the physical and digital worlds of interaction. You and your friends are camping in the jungle. You’re about to go to bed when all of a sudden, hungry wild animals come out to attack you! In this fast-paced game players use a physical slingshot to launch food at a projection of hungry animals. Additionally, a real-life camping display invites people to take pictures as a souvenir. This project is at the intersection of all that New Media Design and New Media Interactive Development offers: design thinking, problem-solving, visual communication, motion graphics, and creative programming.
Plastic Pollution in the Great Lakes
Team: Vanessa Baker, Carmella Bangkong, Olivia Martin, Kristina Chomiak, Dr. Matthew Hoffman, Dr. Nathan Eddingsaas, Dr. André Hudson, Kaeti Stoss
Abstract: This exhibit shows the different types of plastic pollution, the tools used to study it at RIT, and the visualize of how it moves through Lake Ontario, and what the research group is doing to remove debris in the Rochester area. Visitors can get information on local cleanup efforts and the group’s installation of new trash capture devices around Rochester. This project is part of an interdisciplinary research team spanning the sciences and engineering.
Abstract: One of the greatest challenges of managing food waste is participation; we must have participation from people in order to keep food waste out of the landfill and divert it so it is utilized as a resource, not a waste. Households account for about 48% of food waste in the US. This means participation at the household level is key to managing food waste as a resource. The survey seeks to understand household perceptions about food waste management to identify the barriers so we can generate solutions or new services to overcome these challenges and get more household participating!
2019 Large Group
2019 Large Group Award: Forensics Tech and Tactics
Team: Tia Hose, Balen Wolf, Gabriel Corales, Jesse Pickard, Holly Elder, Jade Mullen, April Dumlao, Lin Hui Jiang, Luke Nearhood, Mariam Dzamukashvili, Mary Yuen, Sakinah Abdul-Khaliq, Tommy Tran
Abstract: Our exhibit looks at the different forms of collecting and analyzing forensic evidence. We compare and contrasts various methods and try to determine how reliable each one is. We have interactive games to test the crowd on their crime solving abilities.
2018 Small Group Award: Commercializing Pumice Roofing Tiles in Nicaragua
Team: Thomas J. Higgins III, Karina Alexandra Penaloza, Camila Mota Oliveira
Abstract: This exhibit features the capstone project of three MS Management students trying to help an engineering team from KGCOE commercialize their pumice roofing tile design in Nicaragua. The students are trying to formulate accurate statistical projections to support recommendations for a go-to-market strategy for a new business in El Sauce, Nicaragua. The students are using statistical agency reports on key economic factors (i.e. GDP per capita growth projections, etc.) coupled with local vendor quotations and estimates to try and extrapolate potential market penetration, growth and success factors based on chosen business operation strategies for this new product.
2018 Large Group
2018 Large Group Award: Composting & Recycling: Imagine Sustainability & Food
Team: Stefano Alfredo Agostino, Carmella Mapong Anak Bangkong, Sarah Brooke Bentzley, Matthew Bollinger, Scott Alexander Carlton, Ashley Casimir, Mercy Chado, Alyssa Christner, Ibrahim Cisse, Joshua Thomas Dunn, Tyler Joseph Gamble, Austin Joseph Giacomelli, Aleksandrs Huck, Eric Kelleher, Ethan J. Koval, Katherine Rose Larson, Joelle Christina Marston, Grayson Charles Morin, Alex Nieschlag, Jenny Rose Patterson, Morgan K. Rennie, Elizabeth Ciaccia Rintels, Hannah Elizabeth Schewtschenko, Corbin Frank Shamburger, Yang Shen, Jorge Daniel Soto, Amelia Millicent Sykes, Michelle Wong, Andrew Bernard Yoder, Violet Evening Young, Elizabeth Alice Moore
Abstract: With increasing global challenges such as climate change and inequality, integrated solutions are needed. The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) including quality education, clean water, and no poverty challenge everyone to achieve the goals by 2030. Our Sustainable Development class has researched the sustainability pillars and identified a local sustainable development challenge in the context of the SDGs. Our exhibit highlights multiple solutions to educate the local community on the role they can play in helping to achieve the SDGs through proper composting and recycling practices to reduce waste, lower greenhouse gas emissions, and increase responsible consumption.
2018 Honorable Mention
2018 Honorable Metion: Molecular Glasses Consulting Project - Feasibility of the Automotive Industry
Team: David Even, Katie Green, Rebecca Searns
Abstract: Our project shows our team’s findings and recommendations on whether or not Molecular Glasses, an OLED materials company, should enter the automotive industry. We took this broad question and did extensive primary and secondary research to answer it. We then applied further critical thinking to take the wide breadth of knowledge we discovered and turn it into actionable data. Some examples of business concepts we applied and developed were a condensed value chain, which included a detailed channel analysis, a competitor analysis including a SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces Diagram as well as a market analysis with extensive research.
Team: Julianne Burke, Josh Ladisic, Conner Hasbrouck, Jess Wiltey, Bennoni Thomas, Colton Woytas, Sudarshan Ashok, Vincent Lin
Abstract: A team of 5 designers and 3 developers on the path to creating a digital platform that breaks distance to help people to reconnect with their separated loved ones in a naturally intimate way, leveraging latest wearable technology. In their research of current technological innovations that would serve our goals, the team discovered a technology that determines a user's mood through biological data such as blood pressure, heart rate, breathing pattern and vocal tone. Brainstorming how this technology could be sculpted into a delightful product experience to solve our problem in mind, we conducted ideation sessions to come up with various concepts through multiple rounds of sketching and iteration. Conducting business research to understand which platforms would solve our user needs the best, we noticed trends that showed smartwatch products such as Apple watch or Android wear with increasingly growing market sizes and technological offerings that make implementation of our solution easy. Leveraging the API (Application Program Interface) created by the development team, we worked towards coming up with various iterations of different use cases thus furnishing a quick prototype through which rounds of feedback and additional rounds of iteration were followed. Through further analysis of the wearables market and mentorship advice from professors and alumni mentors from the Silicon Valley, we understood the unique opportunity space to create our own wearable product that lets users share their mood.
2017 Large Group
2017 Large Group Award: Using Innovations in Technology to Combat Violence (Simulation & Behavioral Health: Meet Avatars/SimMan)
Faculty, Staff & Community Industry Mentors: Dr. Caroline J. Easton (CHST, Professor/Researcher and PI); Dr. Richard L Doolittle (CHST, Professor/Faculty Researcher); Meghan Lewis, Alli O’Malley, Nicole Trabold, Cassandra Berbary, Lindsay Chatmon, Brittany St. Jean, Joshua Aldred, Akshay Kumar Arun, Anthony Perez, Karie Carita, Jason Chung, Keli DiRisio
Abstract: Violence is escalating and continues to contribute to the burden of disease at the worldwide level. The negative consequences are devastating to families and society as a whole. The health consequences are numerous and include trauma, substance misuse, depression, anxiety disorders, medical problems and loss of work. The estimated cost to treat victims of violence and offenders is $5.8 billion dollars each year. Compounding this problem is the absence of effective treatments for violence, especially among those who offend violence. Clinicians and policy makers look for answers to help intervene to treat the after effects of violence. We believe that advances in science (e.g., targeted and evidenced based behavioral therapy strategies) can be delivered by interactive technological platforms, which can standardize the way behavioral health problems are screened and treated. Violence is contagious and often multi-generational, which, in turn, requires all necessary means to intervene in ways that are easily disseminated allowing access to evidenced based screening and treatment strategies.
2016 Small Group Award: Robotic Eye Motion Simulator
Team: Amy Zeller, Joshua Long, Nathan Twichel, Peter Cho, Jordan Blandford
Abstract: The objective of this project is to develop a robotic eye that mimics human eye movement to provide a standard for eye tracker testing and to do this within a budget of $2,000. Our senior design team has utilized critical thinking since day one in senior design. It has allowed us to evaluate ideas and to make informed decisions about our project. One of the biggest challenges that our team had to overcome was coming up with a motor to use for our design that both our team and customer agreed upon. An eye tracker is a device that tracks human eye movement and estimates gaze position. Eye trackers have long been used in psychology research, visual system research, marketing, and, recently, as an input device for human-computer interaction. The quality of the data eye trackers output is a fundamental aspect for any research based on eye tracking. There is currently no standardized test method for evaluating the quality of data collected from eye trackers. The lack of standard may lead to research being based on unreliable data. Different manufacturers measure quality using their own methods and researchers either measure it again using different methods or simply report whatever numbers the manufacturer provides. However, the goal of this project is to make the robotic eye affordable, which is necessary to make the use of this eye practical for eye tracker manufacturers and eye tracking researchers to use as a standard. Therefore, our team set out to find a motor that was less than $2,000, had a velocity of 8.73 rad/s and a repeatability of 0.015 degrees.
2016 Large Group
2016 Large Group Award: Your Decisions Make Sustainability Possible!
Team: Jennifer Russell (Coordinator, Golisano Institute for Sustainability) Reema Aldossari, Yi Feng, Shih-Hsuan Huang, Michael Kelly, Nicolas Matthew Miclette, Wilson Sparberg Patton, Wenjing Qi, Kaining Qiu, Elizabeth Stegner ,Jiahe Tian, Akanksha Vishwakarma, Hui-Yu Yang, Yue Zhang, Runhao Zhao (Industrial Design Graduate Students)
Abstract: Our society is facing some significant environmental and social challenges; some of these must be tackled through government and industry initiative, but for many of those challenges the most effective solutions can start right at home with the individual. Our increasing consumption of goods and services is putting significant pressure on our natural systems, as well as on our communities as they deal with increasing waste and resource constraints. We believe that, although consumers may feel helpless to fix some of these problems, in fact they have the potential to be among the most powerful drivers of needed change.
We use this Imagine RIT exhibit to explore how consumers make choices about the products they consume, and how their behaviors and evaluations are affected by new information. Specifically, we seek to understand how the consumer evaluates a ‘greener’ product relative to a ‘normal’ product, and how the product characteristics of ‘cool’ and ‘innovative’ interplay in their choices.